CABARET VOLTAIRE: HAI! (1982)
1) Walls Of Kyoto; 2) 3 Days
Monk; 3) Yashar (version); 4) Over & Over; 5) Diskono; 6) Taxi Music
(version).
The strange fascination of Cabaret Voltaire
with live albums is explainable in two ways: (a) much of their material was
actually developed on the stage, and some of it even never left the stage (Hai! is
a good illustration — three of its songs would only be released in studio
versions after the album, and two
more are only available on the
album); (b) they actually believed that music properly «happens» as interaction
between performer and audience, so that it's better to release a poor quality
live album than a glossed-up studio tape. Well, sometimes, at least.
Stylistically, Hai! is very close to 2x45,
but with one major difference: in place of Chris Watson, the band now features
Alan Fish, trading in their «tape manipulator» for a real live drummer. The
difference is impossible not to notice — particularly when you listen to the
old and the new ʻYasharʼ back-to-back; the song now features fewer electronic
effects, but a wild tribal beat all the way through. What is better? What is
closer to the «true» Cabaret Voltaire spirit? Impossible to tell for me, since
my connection to the band is not really on an emotional level; but at least for
the sakes of a live show, I'd say the choice of a live drummer is a wise one.
All the other songs, too, feature expectable
danceable grooves with dark-gray overtones, similar in mood, tempo, and tone;
the only standout is ʻ3 Days Monkʼ, because of the wah-wah enhanced bassline —
letting out an angry croak that is different from (and somehow feels a little
more personal and communicative than) all the regular dance grooves. I guess
that ʻTaxi Musicʼ is also a standout due to its sheer length (although the
studio recording would be even longer), but since it does not depart too much
from its starting points, 11 minutes is just asking for trouble.
The bass groove can even be poppy if they wish:
ʻWalls Of Kyotoʼ opens the album with a part that could be usable for every
fast-moving song from Joy Division to U2, and maybe even well beyond that
particular time span. But that does little to change things, as the guitars and
keyboards still continue to churn out «sonic muck» more than anything else,
and the only reason why Mallinder spits out those bits and pieces of broken vocals
is to raise the aggression/paranoia bar. Nevertheless, the rhythm section is so
tight throughout that your innate sense of rhythm might eventually placate your
confused sense of melody. I do know at least this about myself — that every
time ʻDiskonoʼ comes on, that simple, repetitive bassline gets me every time.
In short, I give the record a thumbs up — not on an emotional level, but on some
sort of primal level it has that old shamanistic charm, only this time the
shamans exercise a bit more self-discipline.
No comments:
Post a Comment