BRUCE SPRINGSTEEN: HUMAN TOUCH (1992)
1) Human Touch; 2) Soul
Driver; 3) 57 Channels (And Nothin' On); 4) Cross My Heart; 5) Gloria's Eyes;
6) With Every Wish; 7) Roll Of The Dice; 8) Real World; 9) All Or Nothin' At
All; 10) Man's Job; 11) I Wish I Were Blind; 12) The Long Goodbye; 13) Real
Man; 14) Pony Boy.
There are some big problems here that even a
topsy-turvy assessment of Springsteen's like mine could find hard to ignore.
Four years in the making — so long, in fact, that the succeeding Lucky Town caught up with it and both
were released on the same day — Human
Touch finds the Boss jettisoning the E Street Band almost completely,
retaining only Roy Bittan to go on playing the worst kind of synthesizers
imaginable. Even worse, it also finds him moving to Los Angeles, of all places — recording
in Los Angeles — and employing Jeff Porcaro from Toto to contribute percussion,
the rest of his new band members being almost completely unknown.
Perhaps if this album were yet another moody
brooding in the vein of Tunnel Of Love,
where it was all about personality and very little about energy, the flaws of Human Touch might have been overlooked.
But it is not — it is a very blatant attempt to return to the frenzied
arena-rock style of Born In The USA,
or, at least, it is simply a very distinctly pronounced rock album, period. And playing rock without the E Street Band does make him feel a bit like a duck
out of the baking oven... ten minutes earlier than it should be, that is. The
playing throughout is stiff and very «professional» — just your usual session
musicians getting paid for whatever it is that they are getting paid for. Bad
keyboards, overprocessed guitars, and although Jeff Porcaro is quite well
respected in musical circles, next to Springsteen he just doesn't have the same
regal stature as Max Weinberg. This is not his native turf, anyway — why should
he be doing anything other than, you know, drumming?
But the irony of it all is that the songs
themselves, on the whole, are not that much better or that much worse than any
randomly picked tune on Born In The USA
(ʽDancing In The Darkʼ and its absurdly genius synth line excluded). Most of
the time, this is uninventive, but still catchy pop-rock, not as «anthemic» as
it used to be (though some of the songs, like ʽRoll The Diceʼ, unsuccessfully
try to come across as inspiring anthems), just moderately exciting Bruce'n'roll
that does not ask you to worship it but sort of tries to invite you to have a
good time. Repeated listens will let you get over the weakass production, and
then you will understand that very little has actually changed in Bruce's
songwriting ever since he adopted the River
formula. And since he's always been relatively content to go along with the
general musical flow, never distancing himself from the current mainstream
trends, well, no wonder that in 1992 he sounds like they all sound in 1992
(granted, maybe still a little worse: with the grunge explosion hitting hard
and influencing even the veteran rockers, you'd think those guitars could use a
little overdrive without spooking off the population — I mean, ʽMan's Jobʼ
almost sounds like the frickin' Cure's ʽFriday I'm In Loveʼ! not that this
would be bad for The Cure, but it is fairly weird for the Boss).
Thematically, everything here is quite
simplistic — largely just love songs, though every once in a while Bruce still
lashes out tangentially at those weird ways in which the world has developed:
ʽ57 Channels (And Nothing On)ʼ is not the most intelligently written anti-TV
song ever written, but it is a pretty funny satirical blurb for Bruce — a talkin'-blues
musical joke, on which he even took up the bass guitar himself, and whose
message, simple as it is, is unfortunately still relevant for a large part of
the population worldwide. But even in that song, "home entertainment was
my baby's wish", and most of the other songs are quite straightforwardly
about his baby — kind of understandable, considering how Bruce managed to patch
up his personal life after Tunnel Of
Love and was several years into a happy marriage with Patti Scialfa.
The less said about individual songs, the
better. Personally, I am still very much bored when he is getting soft and
sentimental (the title track; ʽWith Every Wishʼ), but it gets much better when
he lets in a little bluesy darkness and a little more hoarse-throated soul
(ʽSoul Driverʼ, with a nice vocal journey from angry verse to pleading chorus),
or when he is just raving and ranting about the fool he has been (ʽGloria's
Eyesʼ, which, if I am not mistaken, borrows the guitar hook from Don Covay's
ʽMercy Mercyʼ, but this is not an album where you're supposed to be noticing
any guitar hooks anyway). Then it gets worse when he stoops to braggardly
cock-rock (ʽAll Or Nothing At Allʼ, where one of the implied lines is
"you'd slip me just a piece of ass",
last word coyly masked as the neutral "it",
but rhymes don't lie!), but again it gets better when he rises to purely
romantic sexism ("lovin' you baby is a man's man's job" — even
despite the song's message sounding so atavistic in the era of gay marriage, the
catchiness of the chorus can't be denied; hopefully, we'll hear a George
Michael cover some day).
Clearly, at 59 minutes this sucker's just plain
overlong: when, towards the end, nearing exhaustion, you are forced to sit
through the triumphantly moronic synth riff and the clichéd masculinity of
ʽReal Manʼ, ideas of progressive taxes on bad songwriting start taking actual
shape. But trim it down to a decent size, and Human Touch shows an artist who may be out of touch and a little out of shape, yet still essentially true
to his formula. Lyrics, production, and energy all show signs of wear — but
what about those of us who were never all that awed by his lyrics in the first
place, and occasionally felt a little embarrassed about those levels of energy?
To those people the deep gap that separates Human Touch from Born In The
USA, or the allegedly even deeper gap that separates it from Born To Run might not feel that deep — nothing that can't be
bridged with, you know, just a little of that human touch.
Nice review. (I think this is your best Springsteen review, probably because it's the most ego-free.) I tend to agree that 'Human Touch' is an average (for most of us: 'quite good'; for George: 'mediocre') Bruce LP. There's nothing greatly wrong with it, but it also -- as you point out -- bears several negative hallmarks of its era. It's overlong, padded-out, and too 'professional' sounding musically. I do think the "Man's Job" type lyrics are to be taken somewhat tongue-in-cheek, but then again if you don't feel that then Bruce mis-calculated.
ReplyDeleteI think Springsteen's comment on this album (and the rather better 'Lucky Town') decades later was, "I tried making happy music. My audience didn't like it." Or words to that effect.
(By the way, 'Tunnel of Love' was recorded in L.A., too.)
I used a lot of parentheses in this comment. (Sorry.)
Poor Bruce. The song 'Human Touch' by Elvis Costello packs more hooks in two minutes than that album does in sixty.
ReplyDelete"the rest of his new band members being almost completely unknown."
ReplyDeleteRandy Jackson wasn't exactly unknown. He had played in Journey and collaborated with Keith Richards recording the film score of Jumping Jack Flash. The other participants only contributed to a few songs - and I wouldn't call Sam Moore (from Sam and Dave) exactly unknown either.
Yes, the Boss took an image hit from the fans at this time -- for ditching the E Street Band and moving to California. He said that he wanting to be challenged by working with different musicians, but this comes across more as dumbing down. The drums sound even worse to me than they do to you - very flat and dull. And if he had to retain one E Streeter, why did it have to be Bittan and his by now stupid synths? The tacky sounds on "Soul Drive" and that too forwardly mixed chime thing on "Real World" are especially annoying. And the title track just a repeat ride through the tunnel of love.
ReplyDeleteI don't really care for any of the ballads, but the rockers are kind of fun and catchy. The lyrics are no more interesting than on the last album, except for "57 Channels". The ouutake "Part Man, Part Monkey" was on the flip, and that resulted in the most humourous single Bruce had ever done. Otherwise, the album is pretty much a one-ear-and-out-the other kind of experience.