ASIA: GRAVITAS (2014)
1) Valkyrie; 2) Gravitas; 3)
The Closer I Get To You; 4) Nyctophobia; 5) Russian Dolls; 6) Heaven Help Me
Now; 7) I Would Die For You; 8) Joe DiMaggio's Glove; 9) Till We Meet Again.
And this thing just flat out refuses to die.
Even with Steve Howe out of the band again, the new old lineup of Asia carries
on well beyond its 30th birthdate, replacing the founding father with Sam
Coulton, whose age — 27 years — means that the band is well on its way to go on
living forever, gradually replacing its grandfathers with their grandkids, as
long as they honor and cherish the big, brawny spirit of Asia. Like Sam
Coulton does.
Is this a good album? Not really. Is this an
Asia album? Very much so, and not in name only. One thing has gone again: the
attempt to connect with the old «progressive» spirit, launched with Phoenix and pretty much dissipated
already by the time of XXX. Gravitas consists of (superficially) catchy,
chorus-driven pop rockers and sentimental pop ballads, almost every one of
which could be a commercial hit single (except that Asia hasn't had a
commercial hit single for over 20 years now, and the public is not likely to make
that change). Sam Coulton is a competent player, and his fluent, melodic style
of playing meets the requirements of Asia, but he is not willing to lead the
band in any daring experiments (and, given the context, would probably be simply
happy to apply his talents to whatever the «veterans» tell him to).
We do know, though, that Asia at their best can
excel in the «arena-pop» sphere as well; unfortunately, the songs that Downes
and Wetton wrote for this record are anything but excellent. Safe, predictable,
and totally respectful of the «Asia formula», they are not even all that catchy,
when you get down to it — numbers like ʽValkyrieʼ and ʽNyctophobiaʼ really only
seem catchy because their hooks just
consist of chanting the title over and over again for about five million times
("Val-kee-REEEEE! Val-kee-REEEEE!", like a drunk Wagnerian, or
"NYC-TO-PHO-BEE-A! NYC-TO-PHO-BEE-A!" like a teacher at the local
spelling bee). The only guitar riff worth of any note is on ʽI Would Die For
Youʼ, and sources indicate that it was actually reworked from an old 1987 demo
— and, frankly speaking, I think I understand why it was shelved, because the
riff is so straightforward and simple that it should have been rather used as a
flashy coda for some other song than as a backbone for an entire composition.
But it is still better than the title track, which uses up two and a half
minutes of «atmospheric» keyboards for the introduction and then becomes a
sentimental bore, hopping along to the rhythm track of Judas Priest's ʽYou Got
Another Thing Comingʼ.
The ballads, meanwhile, show a new low in the
lyrics department: "How did my heart become so soft / Like Joe DiMaggio's
glove?" is quite an excruciatingly extorted metaphor to use as the song's
primary hook, I'd say, but it is nothing compared to the crude romance
interspersed with memories of a night trip from Moscow to St. Petersburg on a
track perversely called ʽRussian Dollsʼ (which really means Matryoshkas, but
could just as well be taken to refer to certain ladies of the night that the
band members might have picked up at the station — well, I'm sure they're all
well-behaved gentlemen, but the lyrics are
ambiguous). And these attempts to add an aura of depth and mystery to mundane
experiences... well, it just doesn't work when all these tired old scales and
production tricks have already been used a million times for that.
So what do we rate a record where the biggest
surprise is a simple riff from 1987, and the biggest disappointment is a total lack
of surprises? A thumbs down assessment seems like the obvious choice, yet, for
some reason, I hesitate to think of Gravitas
as a definitively «bad» record. Maybe as these guys get older, their pompous
arrogance starts being perceived as some sort of melancholic nostalgia, one
with which you could empathize easier than with youthful cockiness-à-la-synth. However cheesy and generic
the arrangement for ʽValkyrieʼ may be, there is no doubt in my mind that Wetton
takes his vocal part seriously and sincerely — "Peace at last, fade to
grey / My war is over now / This is the price I gladly pay / Surrender to her
light" is not the best verse ever written, but this is his clumsy attempt
to convey some genuine feelings on aging and death (and, for that matter, it is
quite easy to forget that the man is pushing 65, just because his singing voice
does not seem to have aged one day since King Crimson's Lark's Tongues In Aspic), and as far as my senses tell me, they are conveyed.
In other words, while formally Gravitas is more «simple» and
«pop-oriented» than the band's «Howe-adorned Renaissance period» albums, it is
a simplicity that logically follows the departure of their most creative
member, not a simplicity born out of an intentionally realised desire to be
simple. There may have been slightly more sophisticated Asia albums in the past
that I actually hated for their arena-oriented pretentious brutal dumbness — Gravitas, on the other hand, somehow
justifies its title, being a little more «earthy», and also a little darker and
bleeker-feeling, than before, and, at the very least, I am sure that old-time
fans, who have aged together with the band, will find it easy to align with the
band's feelings.
Check "Gravitas" (CD) on Amazon
Check "Gravitas" (MP3) on Amazon
Suprised you didn't give it a thumbs down. It's really really boring even compared to their last three records.
ReplyDeleteThey should have packed it after Howe left (trying to balance three parallel careers – Asia, Yes and solo—got to be too much). The band does sound like it’s running out of steam here. Steve had gotten more non-descript on the last album, so replacing him with Coulson doesn’t change the sound as much as one would think. But the new young’un doesn’t add much energy, either.
ReplyDeleteUnlike you, I do think that the change in Wetton’s voice is quite noticeable. His range seemed to have decreased somewhat on the last album, and he got even worse here. That means, for starters, that he can’t quite carry off the bombast needed for the two opening tracks. If he wanted to go back to writing big, pompous lyrics like “Valkyrie” and “Gravitas”, he needed to be able to actually sing them that way, too. The most successful return to a sort of proggy sound is “Heaven Help Us Now”, which contains enough vocal overdubs to complement Downes’s neat pseudo-classical intro.
The thinning out of Wetton’s voice has an unexpected effect on the harmonies of "The Closer I Get to You" – it makes him sound like Brad Delp! If Coulson had added a few more guitar overdubs, it would have sounded even more like Boston. On the other hand, “Russian Dolls”, despite some good lyrics, has a more generic sound. “Nyctophobia” has Downes, once again, employing his Buggles staccato chords. This time, though, the subject matter is so eccentric that it could almost be a Buggles track. It’s no surprise that “I Would Die for You” was demoed for “Astra”, since it has the worst set of lyrics since the reunion. Overall, the lyrics do show a big overall drop from the previous three.
The big exception is the conclusion, “Till We Meet Again”. Another marvelous return to a folky sound musically, and a testament to perseverance in the words. Harmonies that reinforce the message. Hands down my favorite. The song is even more resonant because it’s the last song on the last Asia album with Wetton, ever.
Wetton designated Billy Sherwood to carry on for him, but I don’t know if that was the best idea. My idea for a reasonably legit new/old lineup would be Downes/Palmer/Howe/Payne. But that’s just a fantasy, of course.