Search This Blog

Tuesday, December 3, 2013

Bob Dylan: Desire


1) Hurricane; 2) Isis; 3) Mozambique; 4) One More Cup Of Coffee; 5) Oh Sister; 6) Joey; 7) Romance In Durango; 8) Black Diamond Bay; 9) Sara.

If Blood On The Tracks were Dylan's «silver-age» Freewheelin', then Desire would be his sil­ver-age Blonde On Blonde. Recorded right before the first leg of the famous «Rolling Thunder Revue» tour and officially released in the short interim between it and the less warmly received second leg of the tour, Desire was seriously messy, a little crazy, vastly adventurous, experimen­tal, and, most importantly, inspired. If, ever since, it has been sentenced to the tortuous fate of forever living in the shadows of its much more lauded elder brother, this is still no excuse for ig­noring the younger brother. He may be a tad clownish, but he's an intelligent clown all the same.

In fact, Desire is that particular album where ʽLily, Rosemary And The Jack Of Heartsʼ could have been transplanted to perfect effect, let alone the fact that, even without it, Desire still runs over 50 minutes. It is very much «story-based», partly through the influence of the playwright Jacques Levy, whom Dylan had unexpectedly recruited to collaborate with him on the lyrics (!), but partly, I guess, because Bob was so invigorated by the success of Blood On The Tracks that he was all warmed up for adding a little extra dynamics to his output. Wait, a little? This whole album is like a spacetime-warping travelogue — taking the listener from Rubin Carter's jail cell to the pyramids of ʽIsisʼ, from the «sunny skies of Mozambique» to the valley bellow somewhere in the Promised Land, no doubt, from the gangster wars of NYC to the questionable asylum of Durango, Mexico, and even to some mysterious volcanic island about to be submerged in lava. And best of all, it's not just the words that take you to all those places — Desire is arguably the most musically diverse Dylan album of all time.

To be honest, besides Levy, two more people — both of them ladies, for a change — should re­ceive a heavy dose of the credit. One is the then-young country diva Emmylou Harris, who was only something like half a year into a promising career at the time (Pieces Of The Sky, her first major album, had only come out in February '75), but whose formally «background» vocals here really form part of several soaring duets with Bob: be it ʽOh Sisterʼ or ʽOne More Cup Of Cof­feeʼ or anything else, the two of them are a much stronger pair than Bob could ever be with Joan Baez (Harris' voice is a little more nasal and raspy compared to Joan's glass-shattering vibrato, so it fits in more naturally with Dylan's preferred way of singing).

Even more important, I think — in fact, it's perfectly well made clear ten seconds into the album — is one of those «genius spontaneity» decisions of Dylan's to enlist a girl who was carrying a violin case as he drove by in his limousine. It's a bizarre story, really: she could have had a shot­gun instead of an instrument there as far as we know, but she didn't, and, instead, produced what is probably the finest, sharpest, most emotionally impressive fiddle playing on a Dylan album ever. Nobody knows anything about Scarlet Rivera except that she played on Desire, but she did have a modest solo career afterwards, and some of the tracks from her late 1970s albums (Warner Bros. quickly grabbed her for a couple of LPs, then kicked her back out on the street since they weren't selling) that we can now get easy access to do show the same inventiveness, sharpness, and feel for music. How did the guy spot all that from the window of his limousine?..

Anyway, it is mostly the violin that transforms ʽHurricaneʼ from a spur-of-the-moment political song into a musical masterpiece. You may not give a damn about Rubin Carter and you may not even know two words of the English language, but as long as you know just one — ʽhurricaneʼ — you will be able to spot a subtle, ominous gathering of the clouds in the introduction, and Scar­let's lead violin parts, interspersed with Bob's verses, will be like lightning to the dark, grum­bling clobber of the rain played by Bob's guitar and the rhythm section. If you do know the story, well, this is the angriest that Bob ever got since The Times They Are A-Changin', and arguably even angrier: the song kicks, punches, snarls, bites, roars, and definitely calls to action here, not just to shedding tears for lonesome Hattie Caroll. Was Rubin Carter guilty? Was he innocent? Other than the actual people concerned, who really gives a damn these days? Change the names, change the places, change the motives, it has lost none of its basic, brutal force — like some of those politically charged Lennon songs, it's got magic enough to make one's fists clench them­selves without effort, as naïve and uninformed as some of the actual statements may be. And the way Bob and Scarlet play and sing off each other, trying to outperform the opposite party, still takes my breath away each time.

Of course, the usual consensus is that ʽHurricaneʼ rules and ʽJoeyʼ sucks, because Rubin Carter was an unjustly accused black sportsman and Joey Gallo was a justly murdered white gangster. (Also because the former runs for eight minutes at a brisk tempo, and the latter crawls on for eleven at a snail's pace, but that's just nitpicking). I do not know the backstory — it is not clear if Bob really had any reason to think of ʽJoeyʼ as a «noble gangster» or if this was just another one of his provocative moves. In any case, ʽJoeyʼ is certainly no ʽHurricaneʼ because the violin is not as prominent (its role here is to be more relaxed), but it isn't a bad song — it is a moving tribute to a «street hero», with a sensitively delivered dirge-chorus where Bob, Emmylou, and Scarlet come together in a beautiful three-part harmony (two parts human, one part nylon). It probably did not deserve the honor to be as long as ʽSad Eyed Lady Of The Lowlandsʼ, but apart from that, I couldn't care less about the «real life» person it related to. Remember, he'd done that once be­fore — singing about John Wesley Hardin as if he were some sort of Robin Hood of the West — and if we let him off that time, there is no reason to incriminate him here. It is an abstract tribute song to an abstract criminal with a heart of gold. It could have been ʽAdolphʼ instead of ʽJoeyʼ, that would have made the experience even more hardcore but it wouldn't have made Dylan a Nazist any more than ʽJoeyʼ makes him a gangster lover, or might turn us, the listeners, into gang­ster lovers. It's just a pretty piece of music, albeit a little repetitive.

Fortunately, no such big debate about the non-political masterpieces on here. Nary a weak piece on the block, so it is really tough to choose, but ʽOne More Cup Of Coffeeʼ has long been a per­sonal favorite — Dylan bravely chooses quite an unusual genre to tackle here, a sort of mid-Eas­tern ballad that requires him to actually sing, modulating his voice in a melismatic manner, and gets away with it (although somehow I've always thought that it must have felt very much like taking a quick plunge in ice-cold water for him), while Emmylou on the chorus and Scarlet on the accompanying violin melody once again provide the perfect counterparts. It is one of the saddest songs in his vast repertoire — and in an epic manner at that: "one more cup of coffee 'fore I go to the valley below" sounds pretty much like the last word from a death row prisoner, awaiting to be beheaded in the morning. Prophetic in a way, too, whether there be any connection to his im­pending divorce — or to the impending creative decline.

But Desire is also the last ever Dylan album, or, at least, the last in a long, long time, on which he may sound forceful — energetic, wilful, even occasionally imposing and terrifying, though no­body could say exactly why or how. This is especially so on ʽIsisʼ, which, musically, could be described as Bob's impression of a tired caravan, slowly working its way through the desert — and lyrically does contain elements of a travelog, references to pyramids, and a little proto-Indi­ana Jones feel to it, everything delivered in such a loud, sparkling, indignant tone as if he were reproaching us, the poor listeners, for all of his personal unluck with ʽIsisʼ and the stupid guy who duped him into a tomb-raiding affair. On ʽBlack Diamond Bayʼ, singing from a third person perspective, he is being more detached, but still gives a theatrically engaging reading of the story — a story whose tempo and arrangement are fairly similar to ʽHurricaneʼ, but it really looks like the meditative, melancholic, philosophical brother of ʽHurricaneʼ. Lyrically, you can think of it as an allegory on the meaninglessness of life; musically, you can think of it... well, much in the same way, come to think of it.

ʽOh Sisterʼ and ʽSaraʼ are the most personal songs on here — the latter, in fact, is amazingly straightforward for Dylan, who'd never before dared to get that open on record, certainly not enough to publicly confess about having specifically written one of his songs for a particular per­son (not that the phonetic proximity between Sara Lownds and ʽSad-Eyed Lady Of The Low­landsʼ had ever escaped the attention of keen-eyed Dylanologists, but still, being forced out of the closet is always different from taking the initiative). Both are deeply moving tunes, but ʽOh Sis­terʼ is certainly more «timeless», and has the added bonus of Emmylou and Scarlet playing the collective part of Bob's mysterious «sister» (no, the song is not about incest, or, at least, you'd never be able to prove that in court).

On a personal level, I have to confess that I am still more of a personal fan of Desire than of Blood On The Tracks. Maybe it is simply a case of being mysteriously attracted to the underdog (not that the album has not received its solid share of critical praise over the years), but more likely it is simply a case of being mysterious — there is so much on Desire that is intriguing and enigmatic: the whole album is like a wagonload of boxes that may or may not be empty, but you only have your own imagination and power of interpretation to reach that decision. And, of course, it also has the added bonus of being Dylan's last creative high peak — leaving aside the issue of the late-period «Time Out Of Mind Renaissance», which happened on an altogether dif­ferent scale in an altogether different world anyway, Desire really was the last moment where you saw that bird reeling in the sky with enough boldness, freedom, lust for life and adventure to blow your own mind. That was at the end of 1975. The following year would see an unsuccessful tour, the beginning of transition to a new musical age, the final disintegration of the family unit, a personal mid-life crisis, insecurity, depression, pessimism, all sorts of stuff that would take such a se­rious toll on the Zimmerman brain, he'd never fully recover from it again. Therefore, just join me in my thumbs up here — enjoy it while it lasted — and here comes «the valley below».

Check "Desire" (CD) on Amazon
Check "Desire" (MP3) on Amazon


  1. Eh, I don't know about this one. There are some absolute classics on here, and the vocal harmonies and violin are some of the best sounds in Dylan's entire career, but "Mozambique" and "Romance in Durango" have always struck me as cheap, tourist-y crap, and "Joey" is a maudlin slog regardless of its central figure's character. That's over a third of the friggin' album! The rest is fantastic, of course, and those vocal harmonies and violin are some of the best sounds in Dylan's entire library, but it'll always be a second-tier album to me. (Of course, second-tier for Dylan is still well beyond most others at their best.)

    1. Ugh, accidentally duplicated part of that comment while organizing it. Ignore the twin of your choice.

  2. Plenty of first class-material here. Especially of course Hurricane and One More Cup Of Coffee are masterpieces for the ages, but both Isis and Oh Sister also belong in the upper tier of the Dylan catalog. Sara is haunting, Black Diamond Bay intriguing and Mozambique somewhat stupid but totally irresistible.

    Only Joey is a little disappointing but still ok, and Durango is somewhat stupid and not so irresistible. (check out the totally kick-ass version from the Rolling Thunder tour, though!)

    Still, what's best about this album is the general FEEL. Angry, mysterious, infectious, joyous, mourning, all sometimes mixed together and swirling along with the violin. And totally unique. The true sound of a carnival and the very embodiment of the Rolling Thunder Dylan.

  3. "Hurricane" is indeed a great song. It's a shame Bob didn't research the subject more thoroughly. If there ever was a guilty man it was Reuben Carter.

  4. Musically superb but for every great song there is one that I can easily live without. "Black diamond bay"? Intriguing, amusing, intelligent - everything that makes Dylan a unique artist. "Joey"? Duller than a church sermon. "Hurricane"? Not very subtle but so damn powerful and butt-kicking it makes me wanna go and join a rally or something. "Oh sister"? So dumb and wistful it borders on grotesque. Call me crazy guys but I think that "Blood on the Tracks", "Street-Legal" and even "Planet Waves" are all more consistent in terms of quality. A "Desire" song is either magnificent or horrid. A peculiar case, at least to my ears.

  5. I tend to think that Desire is kinda boring in spots. Joey put me to sleep to Mozambique sounded better on radio than it did on record. Sara is classic, Hurricane does make good use of Scarlet Rivera's haunting violin work and One More Cup Of Coffee pretty good in itself. But in the end, I found the whole record going on too long and actually prefer Dylan's 1978 problematic Street Legal better than Desire, although Dylan has done worse.

  6. She said, "Where ya been?", I said, "No place special"
    She said, "You look different", I said, "Well, I guess"
    She said, "You been gone", I said, "That's only natural"
    She said, "You gonna stay", I said, "If you want me to, yes"

    For some reason these lyrics from Isis always crack me up - they seem more like they belong in speech bubbles in a Peanuts cartoon.

  7. I more or less agree with you that Desire is Dylan's last truly great album until Time Out of Mind - even though I prefer Blood on the Tracks myself. The only real low point on the album is Joey - which might have been an OK song at 5 minutes but, at 10 minutes, totally outstays its welcome.

    Interestingly, I have always felt that Dylan never really ever ran out of inspiration - even in the 1980s - which are universally regarded as the worst period of his career. If he had slowed down the frequency of his album releases (he released 7 albums during the 80s) and actually put the best stuff he recorded on the albums (there is so much great stuff from that period that finally got released on the Bootleg Series), Time out of Mind would not be regarded as any kind of comeback.

    I am particularly peeved by what Dylan did during the Infidels/Empire Burlesque time period. Had the best stuff recorded during those sessions been released on a single album, it would have been phenomenal. I have a playlist that collects those songs together and it is every bit the equal of Blood on the Tracks or Desire.

    Could someone please explain this to me and how that can be a coincidence?

  9. 'Hurricane' was the first Dylan song I've ever heard. By a chance my father downloaded it via some pre-Napster-mp3-sharing program in 2000 and I've been listening to this song over and over again. Boy, it got me hooked. I was fascinated by the playing, the melody, the rhythm breaks, the violin of course. I remember flying to Bulgaria, being bored, and to kill the remaining time I've listened to it 9 times in a row until we landed.

    Couldn't start caring about the lyrics really. From the lines I've picked up like "And though they could not produce the gun" I thought the song was about some native Americans who didn't know how to manufacture firearms.

    After such a high bar I was really let down by Dylan's folk years from the first listen.