BONNIE RAITT: STREETLIGHTS (1974)
1) That Song About The Midway;
2) Rainy Day Man; 3) Angel From Montgomery; 4) I Got Plenty; 5) Streetlights;
6) What Is Success; 8) Ain't Nobody Home; 9) Everything That Touches You; 10)
Got You On My Mind; 11) You Got To Be Ready For Love.
Listen to Takin'
My Time and Streetlights back to
back and you get a valuable lesson in what was deemed «more commercial» and
«less commercial» circa 1974. While some
of the songs on Takin' My Time sound
just like the songs on Streetlights,
the big difference is that everything
that constituted Bonnie Raitt's own artistic sauce has pretty much been ditched
— her guitar playing skills, her diversity in selecting other people's material,
her very important feel for pre-war blues and vaudeville music, and even her
own humble attempts at writing songs.
None of that matters, thought Bonnie's new
producer Jerry Ragovoy, and pushed her towards becoming a «normal» artist —
singing soft orchestrated acoustic ballads, collected from outside contemporary
songwriters. Apparently, the new idea was to market Ms. Raitt as a singer:
Warner Bros.' answer to Karen Carpenter, or something of the sort. Although her
career was slowly gaining traction, with Takin'
My Time finally making it into the Top 100, apparently, they succeeded in
convincing her that a slight image change was necessary in order to attract
larger audiences — and that this image change necessitated dropping Sippie
Wallace covers from her repertoire, for one thing, and replacing them with
something more «relevant».
Okay, says Bonnie, and starts things off with a
cover of Joni Mitchell's ʽThat Song About The Midwayʼ. She nails the sentiment
of the original pretty darn well, but then comes the inevitable: what's the
goddamn point? The arrangement has been made a little more «user-friendly» as
we add some bottom, in the form of a delicate bassline and some soft congas,
and later on, some inobtrusive strings and woodwinds — and you could say that
the vocals also make the song more «user-friendly», since Bonnie's voice is higher
than Joni's, not to mention free from the peculiarities of Joni's irregular
jaw structure, so the average listener might deem Ms. Raitt's rendition «nicer»
than Ms. Mitchell's. But in a different lingo, that same thing is called
«watering down», and I, for one, have no need whatsoever of anybody watering
down Joni Mitchell. Radical transformations are one thing (e. g. ʽThis Flight
Tonightʼ in the hands of Nazareth), but this sort of treatment adds nothing
whatsoever to the original.
Adding almost an insult to almost an injury,
the second track is a cover of James Taylor's ʽRainy Day Manʼ — this time, the
arrangement adds some jazzy electric guitar licks, louder drums, and a heavily muffled
brass and string section, all of them superimposed in such a polite manner that
the song becomes boring almost before it has started. Again, Bonnie does a good
job, but there is no «edge» to the material, and whatever sentiments James
Taylor himself had conveyed through the song, there ain't even a single extra
one here.
The rest does not stray too far away from the
path: songs are reduced to more or less the same soft, «shallow-introspective»
register, regardless of whether they have been penned by overrated superstars
(Taylor) or semi-obscure cult legends (John Prine's ʽAngel From Montgomeryʼ). By
the time we get to the second side, things start heating up a little, as Bonnie
includes several R&B numbers, relatively higher on energy level (Allen
Toussaint's ʽWhat Is Successʼ, with a hilariously «ominous» string
arrangement; Ragovoy's own ʽAin't Nobody Homeʼ, where the brass section is
finally given free reins), but even that idea is discredited on the last track
— ʽYou Got To Be Ready For Loveʼ is a campy proto-disco number that is as far
removed from Bonnie's artistic inclinations as possible (as they hop through
the chorus, I cannot help imagining the lady in ABBA-like glitter, grooving
along to the good vibe, and thinking back on how far people are ready to go for
vague «image demand» purposes).
Nothing, except for that last track, is
properly «bad» — the ballads have occasional hooks, the material has been
chosen with intelligence (after all, covering Joni Mitchell and John Prine can
hardly get one accused of bad taste, right?), and Raitt still has at least the
distinctive feature of being able to make a transition to «rough blueswoman
snap» mode whenever she feels the song might demand it: an important footnote,
because neither a Joni Mitchell nor a Karen Carpenter could have managed this
trick. Unfortunately, she does not resort to it too often, not to mention that
sometimes, due to the nature of the material, it just makes her seem like a
Nashville cowgirl, and that ain't nothing special, either. In the end, Streetlights simply streamlines her
talent, instead of allowing it to develop into something truly outstanding —
and that, woe and alas, is pretty much the way it would generally stay
throughout the rest of her career.