1) U. B. Jesus; 2) The Revolution; 3) The Great Intoxication;
4) Like Humans Do; 5) Broken Things; 6) The Accident; 7) Desconocido Soy; 8) Neighborhood;
9) Smile; 10) The Moment Of Conception; 11) Walk On Water; 12) Everyoneʼs In Love
With You.
General verdict: A musical interpretation of Davidʼs pension
plan, but I certainly do not mean this in a condescending manner. (Plus, his
pension plan probably got a nice fat boost from Microsoft!).
Two things really stick out in David Byrneʼs
first album of new material in the 21st century: his defiantly new coat of
silver-white hair, which would eventually make him look like the other Davidʼs (Lynchʼs) twin brother —
and, of course, ʽLike Humans Doʼ, the song fondly or hatedly remembered by most
users of Windows XP who ever tinkered around with its media player (Iʼve always
been a Winamp person through and through, so I do not have as many haunting
memories of the song as other people claim to have). It is not even clear what
the message of ʽLike Humans Doʼ, a song written from the viewpoint of a foetus,
has to do with Windows Media Player, unless it is meant to be some weirdly
veiled plea to adopt a piece of software. But it did bring David Byrne into a
lot of homes, including many people whoʼd never even heard of Talking Heads, and
at least it was a decidedly less annoying partnership than Apple + U2.
That said, this record isnʼt nearly as fun as Feelings. On the whole, it is smoother
and sweeter, giving us a far more pacified and good-vibe-oriented Byrne than
last time around — an almost 100% turnaround from the gloomy desperation of the
self-titled album, implying that David seems to have finally overcome his
midlife crisis. There is an enormous list of session musicians, most of them
classically trained, turning the album into a sea of chamber and symphonic pop
crossed with the usual African-American and Latin rhythms that are all over the
place, from Seventies-style soul-pop (ʽNeighborhoodʼ) to experimental neo-disco
(ʽDesconocido Soyʼ). But there is no such immediate feel of diversity as last
time around, largely because of the focused attention on strings arrangements
and a largely unified mood all across the record.
Most of the songs are still well-written and quickly
get through; it is just that their charm is all in melodic and lyrical
subtleties, and does not tend to linger long after you have actually soaked in
the song. The opening number, ʽU. B. Jesusʼ, starts out with a mysterious
percussion rhythm that sounds like it came straight out of Tom Waitsʼ Rain Dogs-era textbook, and even the
lyrics, seemingly making fun of the too overtly religious approach to life, are
reminiscent of Tom — but the melodic melange of Latin rhythms, poppy strings,
and gospel backing vocals is a classic bit of Byrne synthesis. Its only problem
is that, like most of the stuff here, it feels a bit whimsical and even
repetitive after a while. But the string riff is cool.
ʽLike Humans Doʼ is actually fairly indicative
of the record at large — a pleasant, toe-tappingly catchy pop song with a lengthy
and well-structured chorus, and an entertaining melody exchange between David
and the accompanying strings and woodwinds. It is rather fluffy, though, even
if it is an intelligent and endearing kind of fluff; I simply happen to feel so
much more connection with David Byrneʼs lyrical hero when he is befuddled and
terrified by stuff happening around him than when he gets all cutesy and cuddly,
with a big childish grin all across his face (or all across whatever a
developing foetus is supposed to have, in this particular case). Even so, there
were times in the past when he was able to get all cuddly and cathartic at the same time — just roll back to ʽThis Must Be The
Placeʼ for a brief while. ʽLike Humans Doʼ, in comparison, has no emotional
peaks — its chorus is smoothly talkative and ends on a delicate question mark
rather than a brusque exclamation point.
This is, however, merely an attempt to explain
why this music no longer lifts me up: it still does a great job at holding me
down while itʼs on, and I will be the first to admit the sorrowful beauty of
the question "whoʼs still workinʼ on his masterpiece?" (ʽThe Great Intoxicationʼ),
or of Davidʼs sentimental croon on ʽNeighborhoodʼ, whose music is all Seventiesʼ
soul-pop but whose vocal and lyrical vibe is all Ray Davies, intimate and
supportive optimism in the face of grim odds. On rare occasions, Byrne still
allows himself to slip into a slightly more grayish mood, and it does not feel
at odds with the rest of the album — ʽBroken Thingsʼ, the hardest rocking song
on the album, is a piece of slow, grinding funk whose dark bass and aggressive
power chords remind you that not all
is well in the house of the aging Byrne City Dweller, but he is working on it.
I think the only piece here that we could all
do without is ʽDesconocido Soyʼ, whose clumsy combo of disco-techno, Spanish
lyrics, and psychedelic background vocals might technically be the most innovative
cocktail on the album — but the effect is annoying, particularly since this puffed-up
ball of dance energy feels stiff and unnatural against the smooth background of
the other songs. Perhaps it is the kind of track that should rather be donated
to some proper Latin artist, provided he or she agreed to take it in the first
place.
The most satisfying thing about the record,
though, is that David Byrne is still David Byrne — even when he is going all
sunshine and rainbows on your ass, you know this is the one guy who will never
succumb to cheap, one-dimensional sentimentalism. As the album closes with its
most honey-dripping tune, BingCrosbishly-titled ʽEveryoneʼs In Love With Youʼ,
a closer look at the lyrics shows that it is actually about ferocious jealousy ("I
want to kill and kiss you too"), but good luck figuring that out from the
basic emotional response to this sweet goodnight lullaby. These little things
help explain why I am intermittently intrigued by this record, charmed by it,
and then bored right out of my skull — not necessarily in that order. In any
case, it is quite recommendable, but, like many others, it shows a formerly
great artist comfortably settling in the overall nonchalance and foggy laziness
of the new millennium — which, I guess, is at least much more honest than
trying to defy Fate and be pretentious in the face of impossibility.
I like 'ʽDesconocido Soy'! It put me off the record on the first listen however later I managed to appreciate the way this simple disco tune incorporates strings instead of that 80s' synthesizer sound.
ReplyDeleteThe strings are very prominent here and it adds to the whole satisfaction I get from the record but the main treat are the melodies. 'Walk on Water', 'Neighborhood', 'Everyoneʼs In Love With You' — very simple, very catchy, quite original. Really not a single downer for me. I understand your general concern that the records lacks the edge of Talking Heads era but not all of the stuff happens to be melodic/catchy AND cathartic/revolutionary at the same time.
Great. Not timeless but great. I'd paint it orange according to your scale.