1) Girls! Girls! Girls!; 2) I Donʼt Wanna Be
Tied; 3) Where Do You Come From; 4) I Donʼt Want To; 5) Weʼll Be Together; 6) A
Boy Like Me, A Girl Like You; 7) Earth Boy; 8) Return
To Sender; 9) Because Of Love; 10) Thanks To The Rolling Sea; 11) Song Of The Shrimp; 12) The Walls Have Ears; 13) Weʼre
Coming In Loaded.
General verdict: One great song, one good song, and I think
the Kingʼs facial expression on the cover of this album pretty much tells you
everything else you need to know.
One can only imagine the level of desperation
in the Kingʼs camp that would have led to the artistically suicidal decision to
resort to a cover of one of Mötley Crüeʼs biggest hits. Not only would the
world at large plunge in a state of total shock to hear Americaʼs golden boyʼs
braggy tales of exploits at Tattletails and Crazy Horse, but to see Elvis with
frizzy hair, in a bikerʼs outfit, drooling at the sight of lusty curves in a
sleazy strip joint...
...oops, sorry, wrong location in the
multiverse. Yes, the girls-girls-girls of 1962 were actually quite different
from the girls-girls-girls of 1987 in details, but the essence of the song is
exactly the same — "Iʼm just a red blooded boy and I canʼt stop thinkinʼ
about [hemoglobin]". Fun trivia bit: the song was originally recorded by
the Coasters a year earlier and was actually written for them by Leiber and Stoller
— with the two unofficially ejected from Elvisʼ circle by the Colonel, the only
way he could still remain in touch with them was through such covers. Interesting,
though, that they even named the movie after the song — I guess a money-packinʼ
idea is still a money-packinʼ idea even if it comes from your enemies. The Coastersʼ
version, by the way, is much more slow and relaxed; the Elvis version is ironically
closer to their ʽYakety Yakʼ schtick, both in tempo and in the trademark yakety-sax
solo by the ever-present Boots Randolph.
Nothing too special, for sure, but at least the
breakneck speed and mildly
hooliganish nature of the title track make it a much better opening than ʽTonight
Is Right For Loveʼ or ʽBlue Hawaiiʼ. Not surprisingly, the album takes a dive
bomb from there — you need only to look at the usual list of songwriters, see
the proceedings completely dominated by Tepper and Bennett, and walk on by. The
usual mix of toothless pop-rockers mimicking past glories and corny ballads
spewing antiquated sentiments... you know the drill.
The name of Otis Blackwell still catches the
eye whenever it comes along, and this time, it does not betray the feeble trust
— ʽReturn To Senderʼ, one of the Kingʼs biggest soundtrack hits, is as good a
pop song as Otis ever wrote. Itʼs not even the melody itself, but rather the
way the song presents itself as a funny, slightly intriguing, narrative —
presenting the rejected narrator not as a longing, yearning, heartbroken person
à la ʽPlease Mr. Postmanʼ, but rather
as a somewhat confused lover who honestly has no idea of whatʼs going on. Plus
the catchiness, plus the wicked bass sax lead lines, itʼs a classic and you
know it. Unfortunately, the other Blackwell tune on the record, ʽWeʼre Coming In
Loadedʼ, is a short, generic, and perfunctory rockʼnʼroll number that seems to
have been specifically written for the purpose of having a song about fishing. (It
is no coincidence that ʽWeʼre Coming In Loadedʼ was written to accomodate the
movie script, while ʽReturn To Senderʼ actually ended up having the movie
script accomodated to it).
Other than ʽReturn To Senderʼ and the title
track, there is little to recommend about this record. Itʼs not that Tipper and
Bennett arenʼt exactly trying — all of their contributions touch upon different
genres and styles — but it all comes out corny in the end, culminating in the godawful
embarrassment of ʽSong Of The Shrimpʼ which is disrespectful to the calypso
genre, the entire shrimp population, and every music listener with at least a
tiny bit of musical taste. ʽEarth Boyʼ is probably the best of all these genre
experiments, a study in «exotica» with a complex musical arrangement, but Elvis
does not seem to be particularly inspired when singing those lines about "earth
boy dreaming of angel".
The only other song from the soundtrack that
was deemed worthy of inclusion onto Command
Performances: The Essential 60ʼs Masters (the «definitive» compilation of Elvisʼ
best material from his movie soundtracks) is Ruth Bachelor and Bob Robertsʼ
sappy ballad ʽBecause Of Loveʼ, whose only point of interest to me is that the
ascending melodic line leading from verse to bridge is exactly the same as on
the Donaysʼ ʽDevil In His Heartʼ (which we all know, of course, from the Beatlesʼ
version). It might be just a stereotypical progression, but it is funny that
both songs were released in the exact same year, so it would be interesting to
know who influenced who. Or, wait, maybe not really that interesting. ʽDevil In His / Her Heartʼ is a much better song
anyway: lots of heartbroken tension there, whereas ʽBecause Of Loveʼ just drips
yucky, sticky honey all over your carpet. No need to bother with it, or with
this album in general.
Hurts to read, since it's Elvis, but I probably would have written the same review. Sadly, he deserves it here.
ReplyDelete"Return to Sender" is up there as one of my favorite Elvis tunes. Just a fun, upbeat, catchy ditty with a great vocal performance from the King. Rest of the album leaves a lot to be desired, but "Sender" is definitely a must-have on any good Elvis compilation.
ReplyDeleteI guess I’m in the minority here, but I like this soundtrack to the Girls! Girls! Girls! movie. Aside from the hit “Return To Sender,” the infectious title tune and the superb “We’ll Be Together” both sound like they could’ve been issued as singles on their own merits, while “I Don’t Want To” and “A Boy Like Me, A Girl Like You” feature some of Elvis’ best ballad work. “Thanks To The Rolling Sea” is another fine number with a great use of the Tom Tom drums, and I even like “Song Of The Shrimp” although I can definitely see George’s point. “We’re Coming In Loaded” ends things excitingly. Love live Girls! Girls! Girls!
ReplyDeleteGeorge, please, find some artists you enjoy and write reviews of their albums. I miss your positive reviews.
ReplyDeleteExactly, because it’s obvious that George isn’t much of an Elvis Presley fan and I feel sorry for him.
DeleteI honestly do not know if I should be laughing or crying at these comments, gentlemen.
Deletehttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fan_(person)
DeleteJudging by the reviews, George recognizes Elvis as an important figure in the pop/rock world, but he's not crazy about his actual albums. But as the avid historian of rock that he is, he will slog through his whole discography.
ReplyDeleteThis would be a great moment for George to review Danzig Sings Elvis!
ReplyDelete