1) Thank You For Sending Me An Angel; 2) With Our Love; 3) The Good Thing; 4) Warning Sign; 5) The Girls Want To Be With The Girls; 6) Found A Job; 7) Artists Only; 8) I'm Not In Love; 9) Stay Hungry; 10) Take Me To The River; 11) The Big Country.
General verdict: In a perfect world, THIS would have been the ultimate breakup album. After all, if you're not in love anyway, you can never truly break up.
Almost half of the songs on the Heads'
sophomore album can already be found among the heavily bootlegged 1975 demos — typically,
this is not a very good sign, but in the Heads' case, this merely meant that
their artistic progression from 1977 to 1978 was not as phenomenal as it would
be over the next two years. Even the title is somewhat self-conscious: it can
be debated if «buildings and food» were indeed the primary topic of '77, but «more songs about...» is telling anyway. There are plenty of
additional subtle nuances here that the debut record lacked (many of them
certainly due to the presence of Brian Eno as co-producer and guest musician),
but generally, it all falls under the «if you liked X, you will like Y»
scenario.
I remember that upon first hearing the record,
almost everything on it felt like one long, frantic, shaking, wobbling,
paranoid funk jam, with insignificant variations in tempo and tonalities; only the
much slower, soulful-ler ʽTake Me To The Riverʼ stood out from among minutes
that felt like hours while David Byrne was letting himself be gradually and
sadistically electrocuted. Repeated listens have altered this perception, of
course; these songs owe as much to The Beatles as they do to James Brown — it
is not for nothing, after all, that ʽThank You For Sending Me An Angelʼ opens
the record with the galloping pattern of ʽGet Backʼ. It is simply that the
manners and the antics of the Heads are so uniform that no matter whether they
are leaning more towards pop or towards funk, it all ends up sounding like
pages from David Byrne's diary.
Which, for that matter, starts out at the
beginning of days, since on ʽThank Youʼ David pretty much assumes the role of
Adam, freshly introduced to Eve: "Oh baby, you can walk, you can talk just
like me... you'll walk in circles around me". If there is a better symbol
of Talking Heads as the beginners of a new era — not just in music, but in
human perception — if there is one, I cannot be bothered to go look for it,
since this grand opening suits me just fine. Its message and its function are
not that different from ʽUh-Oh, Love Comes To Townʼ, though: both songs are
fairly upbeat and superficially optimistic eyes-wide-opened looks at the opposite
sex — followed by miles upon miles of second thoughts, doubts, panics,
penances, phobias, rejections, and whatever else there is in store for the
tense and nervous psycho killer.
Indeed, the lyrics on this album are so good
that it is easy to fall into the trap of simply discussing Byrne's views on
relations and sexes instead of paying much attention to the music. Therefore,
perhaps it is better to bring up, first and foremost, the case of ʽStay Hungryʼ
— a song whose words probably
describe the terrifying aspects of physical contact, but only really serve as
an introduction to a lengthy funk jam, with Byrne and Harrison locking
themselves into man-machine guitar grooves and Eno providing ghostly ambience
with a synthesizer part that may have as well been stockpiled from his own
sessions for Before And After Science.
There is an ominous, scary effect in this recording that is hard to find in
more traditional funk music — a bit of a hand-of-doom manifesting itself
through the players, almost as if they felt they had fallen upon the pulse of
life itself, which energizes them to no end but also scares the shit out of
them. And Eno — Gandalf the Grey of the musical world — is just the perfect companion
for them on this voyage: his creepy ambient textures are just the kind of imaginary
ghosts that the Byrne character would be likely to be haunted by most of the
time. Even when he is trying to make love to his girlfriend, because, as he
knows, "the girls want to be with the girls" and physical contact
between man and woman is odd by nature.
See, even now I am still sliding over to the
lyrics, but what can I do? ʽThe Girls Want To Be With The Girlsʼ is arguably
one of the greatest and most complex commentaries on the male/female issue in
the history of pop music: "there is just no love / when there's boys and
girls", he concludes, making the song into more of a psychological
lecture set to music than an actual song (though not before lifting the melody
of the Kinks' ʽTired Of Waiting For Youʼ for the main theme, which makes the
whole thing even more ironic). If you need specific examples, you have ʽFound A
Jobʼ, where a boy and a girl are only able to «save» their relationship by
working together on storylines for TV shows — a concept as ridiculous in nature
as is the song's music in sound (the instrumental coda is like trying to play a
funk groove and a steady military march at the exact same time — the awesome weirdness
of this is particularly well illustrated by the band's body movements in the Stop Making Sense video). "So think
about this little scene, apply it to your life / If your work isn't what you
love, then something isn't right" — right on, brother.
The greatest artists are those for whom no cows
are sacred, and in between terror-funky depictions of his non-sex life, Byrne
also finds the time to insert a poke or two at modern stereotypes, including
his brothers in artistry: "I don't have to prove... that I am
creative!" (ʽArtists Onlyʼ) — and at ancient stereotypes, including peace
and happiness of rural life. I mean, you might think that after having so many
breakdowns against the background of urban life, Byrne might really take after
Ray Davies in his love for the village green, but no dice: "I wouldn't
live there if you paid me / I wouldn't live like that, no siree!" is his
proclamation on ʽThe Big Countryʼ, a song radically different in structure,
finishing the herky-jerky album on a slower, steadier, more traditional note
with a lyrical slide guitar-driven melody. It is not a great song (the slide
hook is nice, but gets very monotonous and repetitive after a while; Jerry Harison
is, after all, no George Harrison, and I have not only waited a long time to
say that, but also found a perfect pretext for saying it) — not a great song,
but a perfectly placed conclusion to an album that is all about urban paranoia,
yet ultimately refuses to seek refuge from it in any imaginary, hypothetical
pastoral paradises.
But before we make a final slide across the ʽThe
Big Countryʼ, there is ʽTake Me To The Riverʼ, one of the (three) biggest
singles in Talking Heads history and the song that more or less put them on the
map for everybody who did not have the privilege of being a CBGB resident. The
funny thing is that Heads recorded their version almost at the same time as
Foghat, Levon Helm, and Bryan Ferry —
but the public took to theirs (though, allegedly, only the Heads released
theirs as a single rather than an LP track). Perhaps it was because they found
the perfect tempo for it, so that Tina's bass line could be that perfect
restraining anchor. More likely, because Al Green's complex message of love,
sin, and redemption fits right in with Byrne's idea of love as an illusion and
a virtual impossibility. Green's song was a bit of an enigma from the start —
it is never explained whether the protagonist is baptized in love or against love —
and it kinda remains that way in Byrne's paranoid interpretation. Perhaps more
importantly, it is the first explicit link between Talking Heads and the old African-American
tradition, and, even more importantly, it is not an attempt at a modernistic
deconstruction, but a melodically loyal cover — a symbolic acceptance of the old
values and the old issues that remain as valid for this new artistic age as
they had ever been. (Of course, the Heads were not unique in this acceptance;
but the sound of '77 was such a
radical departure that my guess is, they made a very conscious move to include
ʽTake Me To The Riverʼ on this album just to reassure the world that they were
not, in fact, a bunch of aliens. Or if they were, at least they were aliens that
spent some time in the church of Al Green).
It only goes to show how phenomenal this band
was, really, if I find nothing but good things to say about an album that I
very rarely listen to — partly because, as in the case of its predecessor,
almost all of the songs here sound much better live, and partly because so few
of them are truly outstanding. In less than a year, Talking Heads would go all ambitiously
epic on our asses; here, they were still learning the ropes and keeping a
relatively low profile. But just like the «teen Beatles», the «teen Heads» have
a special charm (or, probably, anti-charm
would be a better term) whose anti-innocence would no longer show on subsequent
records; and from that point of view, more songs about buildings and food are
always welcome. Even if by «buildings» they mean «inability to form a loving
relationship with anything that is not made out of wood or stone».
I’ve always had mixed feelings about this one, feeling that the songs were overall a step down in quality from the debut and that the band had not quite figured out how to integrate their style with spooky Eno electro-ambience to the best possible effect yet. That being said, Big Country is one of the best songs the band would ever do. The resolution on the chorus- ‘I wouldn’t live there... if you PAID. ME. TOOOOO!!!’- is one of the most cathartic moments in the TH catalogue.
ReplyDeleteI agree that in some respects the entire sensibility of this album, and maybe of the Heads generally, is a novel approach to exploring the by-now well-worn theme of urban alienation. The quirky repudiation of cliched pastoral solutions definitely drives that home.