CATHERINE WHEEL: HAPPY DAYS (1995)
1) God Inside My Head; 2)
Waydown; 3) Little Muscle; 4) Heal; 5) Empty Head; 6) Receive; 7) My
Exhibition; 8) Eat My Dust You Insensitive Fuck; 9) Shocking; 10) Love Tips Up;
11) Judy Staring At The Sun; 12) Hole; 13) Fizzy Love; 14) Kill My Soul.
As the first guitar chords of ʽGod Inside My
Headʼ appear on the horizon, the horrible thought enters your mind — «Christ!
They must have swapped my copy with a bootleg of Metallica outtakes!» Relief
will come pretty soon, but the chugging opening is fairly symbolic: it
represents Catherine Wheel's ultimate denial of the atmospheric shoegaze
ideology and their further advance into the realm of modern heavy rock. Thrash
influences are actually quite thin here, compared to the power-chord based
grunge / alt-rock legacy, but overall, it is clear that they want to try their
hand at «brute force psychedelia» now, rather than simply «distorted guitar
psychedelia».
Veteran fans and critics, as far as I can tell
in retrospect, despised this decision, but honestly, it was just a fairly
logical continuation of the evolution that had already started on Chrome. Perhaps they really were trying to sell out, taking after
Bush rather than My Bloody Valentine, but the most important element of the
Catherine Wheel sound, the Dickinson/Futter guitar interplay, remains firmly in
place, so all they really did was take some focus off the atmosphere and invest
it in riffage and power. Admittedly, I cannot insist that it was a correct
decision: Dickinson is no heavy metal riffmeister, and I have a hard time
trying to remember if there was at least one heavy guitar pattern on this
entire record that rocked me to the bone like a Nirvana or an Alice In Chains
song can often do. (ʽHoleʼ probably comes closest, but still not close enough).
But let us begin with the singles. ʽJudy
Staring At The Sunʼ was the first one, with a title more fit for a Belle &
Sebastian record, perhaps, and very little of the band's usual sonic
inventiveness — the song puts far more trust in the romantic repetitiveness of
its title, where Dickinson is joined by Tanya Donelly of Throwing Muses in the
quest to raise a little band of angels in support of the world's latest
imaginary spiritual martyr ("Judy's day passed out of sight, Judy will be
suffering tonight", because it serves you right to suffer, as John Lee
Hooker told us earlier). It's not a bad song, except that one or one dozen or
one hundred more or less like it was probably written by every British guitar
band in the 1990s, and this one, I must admit, does not even make good use of
the Dickinson/Futter combo (just the same predictable distortion / jangle
pairing throughout, without any attempts to change direction).
The real low point was probably the second
single, only released briefly for promotional purposes: ʽLittle Muscleʼ is
about... no, it's not about what you probably think (you pervert! I thought about it earlier than you anyway!),
it's about, hmm, licking a letter to one's lover with one's tongue, which is sort
of the most natural thing to do for a Catherine Wheel song protagonist. The
song is short, silly, alternates between quiet and loud passages just like
Blur's ʽSong 2ʼ, but without any shades of irony or parody. I suppose that if
we really start judging the merits of the album by this kind of song, all criticisms are justified... then again, it was one of the singles. And so was ʽWaydownʼ,
which really sounds like a weak attempt to ape the structural and emotional
style of Nevermind — loud, quiet,
loud, quiet, scream, desperation, noisy guitar break, post-teen angst, but they
still can't nail it with as much conviction as Cobain could, maybe perhaps,
unlike Kurt, Mr. Dickinson really
does not have a gun (fortunately for him, in the long run).
Yet again, this does not mean these loud,
short, and totally non-outstanding songs are completely typical of the album.
Its centerpiece, for instance, is an eight-minute Talk Talk-ish epic (the least
Talk Talk-ish thing about it is its offensive title — ʽEat My Dust You
Insensitive Fuckʼ) that's all atmosphere, alternating between soft and subtle
guitar/organ textures and squeaky-swampy harmonica breaks with dark side
overtones. Another highlight is ʽHealʼ, with a beautifully modulated vocal part
from Dickinson: fulfilling the «power ballad» role on this album, it knows when
to tone down the grinding distortion and place its faith in the old-fashioned
Hammond organ, and the quiet "everyone needs someone" coda has that
soulful-melancholic Peter Gabriel / Mark Hollis vibe to it; I wish there were
more moments like these on the record, because if you're going to copycat
anyway, why not choose the right
models?
Besides, it's not as if the album is simple
enough to fit into the «if it's long, it's atmospheric and mesmerizing; if it's
short, it's stupid and boring» formula. I really like ʽHoleʼ, for instance,
which sounds nothing like the real Hole, but is a shapelier alt-rocker than
most of the other ones, funkier and with some sneery arrogance in the chorus
melody to add to the generic paranoid / pissed-off alt-rock feel. And elsewhere
I just wait for the instrumental break, because Futter still dutifully solos
like a beast every now and then, saving the band's reputation as best as he can
(ʽEmpty Headʼ, for instance). On the whole, you know, I couldn't really bet my
head that Happy Days is an objective
letdown, in terms of composition, after Chrome
— and Catherine Wheel were never about pure atmosphere from the very beginning,
either. It does, however, place them in the rather insecure and risky position
of diluting their identity, which was never all that outstanding in the first
place — and, of course, once we shake the cobwebs away and realize that 1995
was also the year of The Bends, well...
there's only so much space in one's head that one should feel free to allocate
to music like this, and for 1995, Radiohead occupy most of it anyway.
In 1995, Tanya Donelly had been out of Throwing Muses for years and had released two albums with Belly. I'd love to read your thoughts on those.
ReplyDelete