1) Out Of The Blue; 2) Left & Right In The Dark; 3) 11th Dimension; 4) 4 Chords Of The Apocalypse; 5) Ludlow St.; 6) River Of Brakelights; 7) Glass; 8) Tourist.
General verdict: An unexpectedly solid mix of Sixtiesʼ, Seventiesʼ, and Eightiesʼ influences, not to mention the conceptual time machine all the way back to 1900.
"The first duty in life is to be as artificial
as possible", thus begins Oscar Wildeʼs Phrases And Philosophies For The Young, and "To love oneself is
the beginning of a life-long romance" is how it ends — and now just look
at this album cover and everything becomes crystal clear. Some might wonder why
Julian Casablancas even felt a need to make his own solo album when he had
always been the primary creative force in his own band, but the thing is, the Strokes
are a band, and the band members do
happen to have creative differences — one of the reasons why Angles, the much awaited follow-up to First Impressions Of Earth, was held up
for such a long period. The way I see it, Casablancas is more of a Mick Jaggerish
presence in the band, whereas Nick Valensi is somewhat more Keith Richardish —
a very rough and symbolic approximation, of course, given that none of them
ever really sound like the Stones, but then I guess itʼs just a nice analogy
that can always be used to describe the opposing forces of the vocalist
frontman and the guitar-wielding sidekick in any rock band, so there you go.
Anyway, when I first skimped through some
descriptions / reviews of Julianʼs solo album, I ended up with the wrong
impression that he wanted to make an electronic dance-pop record or something
like that, and that Strokes fans who like their guitar music would probably be
seriously disgruntled about this. Fear not, though. The record does feature quite
a bit of synthesized keyboards, as well as programmed drums (Casablancas played
most of the instruments himself), but its overall sound and style is not that
much removed from the usual Strokes vibe. It is most certainly not an
easy-going rockʼnʼroll record, but neither were First Impressions; with each new album, the Strokes were
progressively demanding more and more to be taken as serious artists, and Phrazes For The Young is simply the
next step.
Surprisingly, the album is pretty damn good. First
and foremost, Julian corrects the biggest mistake of First Impressions — trims down the length: there are but eight
tracks here, amounting to about 40 minutes worth of music. Second, there is an
interesting flow to the tracks: the album sucks you in with a few relatively
catchy and upbeat numbers, gradually makes you come to terms with the alliance
between analog and electronic equipment, then slows down into pensive,
singer-songwriterish territory. By the time itʼs over, you might have stopped
paying close attention, but you might still be subconsciously influenced by the
constant shift of direction so much that your brain might give off a small «thatʼs
it? I want more!...» impulse, whereas with First
Impressions, it was more of an «enough already!...» after a while.
The album opener ʽOut Of The Blueʼ is the slightly
deceiving Strokes-like opener, a fast-paced, catchy pop-rocker with a «dual
core» of rapidly strummed guitars and organ-like synthesizers in classic Blondie
mode — plus a bunch of psychedelic lead guitar overdubs later on. The lyrics
are moderately cryptic and confusing, and even if Julian finishes his odd personal
tale with "thatʼs all Iʼm gonna say now before they come knockinʼ on my
door", I think that he still got plenty of time before "they" actually
figure out why the hell are they supposed to knock on it in the first place, unless
they take the line "somewhere along the way my anger turned to vengeance"
too literally and send in a bomb expert or something. But I do like the overall
mood — the bitter-cynical vocals, the romantic electronics, and the
hallucinatory lead guitars generate an odd atmosphere of hipster coolness that
you do not always get on a typical Strokes record.
The next two songs are easily the cheeriest and
most synth-pop-like on the whole album, though, ironically, ʽLeft & Right In
The Darkʼ reminds me less of the Cars than it does of Dire Straitsʼ ʽWalk Of Lifeʼ
— utilizing the same trick of drilling a happy keyboard riff in your head even
before the full arrangement kicks in. The build-up from verse to bridge to
chorus is quite decent, even if the idea of using "wake up, wake up"
as the vocal hook for the chorus might seem trite and over-worn — and it is
useless to hope that Julian Casablancas, the one-man band, may be capable of outplaying
Arcade Fire. Still a good song, as is the follow-up, ʽ11th Dimensionʼ, probably
the biggest throwback to the Eighties on the album — sounds like a bittersweet ABC
pop anthem (though Martin Fry would probably shy away from a lyric like "I
live on the frozen surface of a fireball / Where cities come together to hate
each other in the name of sport").
The record then undergoes quite a drastic
shift, as the ironically titled (since it utilizes a fairly standard chord
progression) ʽ4 Chords Of The Apocalypseʼ slows it down to the heart rate of a meditative
country waltz, as if Julian suddenly decided to go all Gram Parsons on our
asses. This is where things get seriously unexpected — it was pop-rock before
that, and now we are in full-blown singer-songwriter mode, and even the vocals,
usually processed and distant, are now moving in closer and trying to weave a
blue-eyed soul atmosphere around you. Is it good? I am not sure about that, but
it startled me, and thatʼs probably the most I can ask from this guy. After
this, ʽLudlow St.ʼ continues the slow balladeering vibe, as Julian gets
symbolically drunk, picks up inspiration from Leonard Cohen — maybe? — and attempts
to connect his own story with that of Ludlow St., going all the way back to
1624... with a banjo on his knee, no less.
This new feel permeates the record until the
very end — youʼd think it were a bit risky, not to mention arrogant, to end the
album with a song called ʽTouristʼ, but in truth, it is melodically more
similar to a Neil Young ballad than anything by Radiohead: in fact, even just
glancing at the lyrics ("I feel like a tourist, out in the country...")
and remembering how the chorus hook goes makes me think old Neil would have a
blast with this song, maybe throwing in a bit of dirty fuzz over its nifty
little acoustic riff. Granted, all this deep melancholy does seem a little
artificial for a comfy urban guy like Casablancas — but then, remember, "the
first duty in life is to be as artificial as possible", isnʼt it?
All in all, do not be surprised, but I think
that this is Julianʼs best offering since Is
This It — simply because the solo format has allowed him to do something ever
so slightly different and expanding at once into two completely opposite
territories (synth-pop and traditional singer-songwriting stuff). It is
absolutely not enough to make me go wow and welcome the guy as the new
definitive spokesman for his generation, or even to justify the comparison
between himself and Oscar Wilde, but he has managed to make himself more
interesting to me with this record, and I might even want to spend a bit more
time with it to understand why.
I agree completely. This got buried on the back of a Pitchfork review and little else. It strikes me as pretty much the perfect balance between Strokes and indie electronica. Granted, I find most of the songs on the second half to be rather clunky and awkward, but the first is one of my favorite album halves in the genre (with "Left & Right..." one of my favorite tracks).
ReplyDeleteIt's worth pointing out that Casablancas's further solo work with his other band The Voidz has tended to be more well-received critically than any of the Strokes albums after Is This It. You might be pleasantly surprised once you get to it in your Strokes reviews.
ReplyDeleteThis album has great moments, but I'm always annoyed by Julian's singing here (and on First Impressions). Regardless, the last decade of Julian's work is set up by Phrazes as those retro and experimental sounds are so important to the Voidz and the Strokes' recent works. Hope you review the Voidz after the next two Strokes albums.
ReplyDeleteNext three Strokes albums. They've dropped a new album this year.
DeleteIf George continues to review chronologically, the Voidz are after Comedown Machine, making it two Strokes albums. The New Abnormal would come right at the end.
Delete