BORIS: SOUNDTRACK FROM FILM MABUTA-NO URA (2005)
1) Theme; 2) The Middle Of The
Stairs; 3) A Bao A Qu; 4) The Slow Ripple Of A Puddle; 5) Your Name; 6) White
Warmth; 7) Melting Guitar; 8) Yesterday Morning; 9) Amber Bazaar; 10) Smoke
Sequence; 11) Space Behind Me, Part 2; 12) The Picture Of The Wind; 13) It Touches.
«Imaginary film», the title should read,
because no film with the title of Mabuta-no
Ura («Under the Eyelids») actually exists — Boris simply stated that they
imagined this film in their minds, and then wrote the soundtrack to their
imagination. Now — if that ain't art,
then what is? How much more artistic, spiritual, transcendental does one get
than writing music to accompany visuals that appear under your eyelids,
triggered by the mystical force of imagination?
But there's some bad news, too. As awesome as
the mystical force of imagination really is, the sobering reality is that most of the time, the force makes you imagine
all sorts of random crap (I bet you can agree with me on that one). Consequently,
once you try writing music to imagined random crap, you are quite likely to end
up consciously writing crappy music to accompany the subconscious results of
your imagination. And since Boris have no songwriting talents whatsoever
(there, I've said it), and their main appeal lies in their «tones» and «minimalistic
attitude», it is only logical that the final result is an absolutely pointless
bore.
«At least the tracks are short this time», you
could say, and you'd be wrong, because with long
tracks, the band at least has a point — debatable, but a point nonetheless. These
short bits, though, are simply meaningless. With ʽThemeʼ, you think you could
possibly expect a «theme», but what you really get is a two-minute long droning
alarm call in a tunnel, or so it seems. Impressionistic? Symbolic? Psychedelic?
Whatever. ʽThe Middle Of The Stairsʼ follows it up with two minutes of slow
acoustic/electric strumming where we are probably supposed to luxuriate in the
combining humming overtones of the two instruments — hey, if you thought you
knew how to appreciate the guitar sound before hearing Boris, hear Boris and
think again.
Following up on that, the soundtrack gets more
and more diverse, but that is exactly the most terrifying thing about that: no
matter what they do, it all sounds derivative, meaningless, and dull. ʽThe Slow
Ripple Of A Puddleʼ — yes, about as exciting to listen to as the slow ripple of
a puddle, and I cannot even defend it on the grounds of «minimalist philosophy»,
because the little guitar loop that they use here has no deep emotional power
of its own to warrant becoming the focus of the track. ʽYour Nameʼ features the
band playing a rudimentary hard blues tune: three and a half minutes of what
sounds like a 12-year old Neil Young practicing his first scales. ʽMelting
Guitarʼ — okay, with a title like that you'd expect a massive sludge metal
eruption or something, instead, it is simply a little more meandering
free-form droning, sort of like what you get in the mid-section of King
Crimson's ʽMoonchildʼ, only much more aimless.
Anyway, to cut a long unnecessary story
mercifully short, the only track here that merits the slightest consideration
is ʽIt Touchesʼ. Closing out the album, it runs longer than the rest and has a
rather cool, even hypnotic, bass/drums groove, against which all of Wata's
little guitar tricks may be perceived as colorful flourishes rather than just
pointless doodling. Nothing particularly great, that is, but pretty much a
musical masterpiece compared to all the other small bits. Then again, the best solution is to cut the bullshit
and simply ignore the album altogether. Total thumbs down — I'm so desperate,
I'd rather even have me some John Frusciante than this.
Somehow negative reviews seem more satisfying to read than positive ones; reading someone spew proverbial vitriol is all the more exciting than proverbial sugar.
ReplyDeleteBy the way, is it safe to assume that Boris will get one of the "black sad/mad faces" on the HTML version of the site accessible through your old site?
Please, "anti-smileys" is the term.
DeleteEh, George will probably view them the same as Animal Collective and Boards of Canada, over hyped but not so egregiously to the point of Bon Iver.
DeleteI can't wait to see his reaction to the New album, he's bound to be in for a shocker with THAT one