AEROSMITH: MUSIC FROM ANOTHER DIMENSION! (2012)
1) LUV XXX; 2) Oh Yeah; 3)
Beautiful; 4) Tell Me; 5) Out Go The Lights; 6) Legendary Child; 7) What Could
Have Been Love; 8) Street Jesus; 9) Can't Stop Loving You; 10) Lover Alot; 11)
We All Fall Down; 12) Freedom Fighter; 13) Closer; 14) Something; 15) Another Last
Goodbye; 16*) Up On A Mountain; 17*) Oasis In The Night; 18*) Sunny Side Of
Love.
Word of the day is «tedious». Seven years in
the making, during which the band almost came to a complete halt (as Joe Perry
started spreading rumors that Aerosmith would go on with a new lead singer) —
eleven years, actually, since the world's greatest rock'n'roll band, MTV-style,
graced us with their last all-original collection of tightly polished,
relentlessly professional, thoroughly washed-up rock-a-pop. And now — not only
are they back, but what they are offering us is Music From Another Dimension. Sure thing, guys. Any dimension in
which Diane Warren may be residing at present is definitely another by me.
If, like poor deluded me, you ever thought that
the not-particularly-inspired, but still relatively tough, blues-drenched, Honkin' On Bobo gave a weak hint at
salvation, and that the subsequent live release so strongly reminded us of what
was ever so great about Aerosmith in the first place — forget all hopes even
before you put the record on. The album cover is cheesier than ever, and once
again, they fall back on their corporate songwriter squad: Marti Frederiksen!
Jim Vallance! Desmond Child! Russ Irwin! And, oh yes, Lady Di in person, with a
brand new power ballad and she's not afraid to use it. If you thought these
guys were long since packed in naphthalene, you got another think coming.
Another dimension has opened up, and the living dead are upon us.
Except that even the living dead, as it turns
out, are not immune to aging. Where «classic late period Aerosmith» managed to
become an outrageous offense to good taste while still retaining a serious
level of energy and catchiness, Music
From Another Dimension is nowhere near as offensive (it is not altogether
«mentorial», with neither the carnal nor the humanitarian save-the-world side
of these guys over-emphasized as usual) — it is simply dull. Long, overdrawn,
repetitive, monotonous, and deadly, mind-numbingly D-U-L-L.
No one has bothered writing a single new
interesting riff. At best, you get rehashes of ʽLast Childʼ, ʽDraw The Lineʼ or
even ʽWalk On Downʼ, and at worst, you just get the basic wall of stiffly
produced sound that Aerosmith can produce in their collective sleep, having
built up so much experience since 1987. Yes, it all sounds like Aerosmith — why
should it all sound like anybody else? — and it all sounds tired. Of course, they
are old men, and one has to lower the expectations in proportion to age. Or
has one, really? With a million and one bands in the world still punching out
loud rock'n'roll, why settle for somebody just because they are — just because
they used to be — Aerosmith?
Take my advice, if you wish, and make your
decision based on the very first track, since most of the rest will sound more
or less the same way. Loud, compressed, based on a blues-rock melody taken
directly from the stockpile, and featuring multi-tracked vocals from Tyler that
finally show serious signs of aging — he is quite consciously sparing his throat
after the surgery performed in 2006, and avoids overtaxing the larynx.
Obviously, he cannot be blamed, but it is just as obviously clear that,
without Tyler's vocal antics, Aerosmith is going to look no happier than the
three-legged dog on the cover of an Alice In Chains album. (For honesty's sake,
Steve can still hit his famous high notes, but he only does this in exceptional
cases now — mostly saving it up for the «climactic» moments of the
album-closing ballad, ʽAnother Last Goodbyeʼ, and, actually, it isn't all that
pretty any more). And then there are the air-brushed lyrics, no longer dripping
sexy sweat as they used to, but somehow it seems that the taming is more
generally due to the overall aura of political correctness flowing in the air
than the wise decision to finally «act their age»: "Love three times a
day, love your life away... there ain't no other way, it's in your DNA" —
sounds like a Viagra commercial to me, don't you think?
In terms of general «musical philosophy», the
album continues the line of Just Push
Play, subtly erasing the line between «rocker» and «ballad» and throwing on
poppy lines and psychedelic hugs every now and then — but it also cuts down on
the most overtly «Beatlesque» moves of that album; on a purely formal basis, Another Dimension rocks harder (on an
intuitive basis, it does not rock at all). Will this please old-time fans? Not
sure. Even with the fast-moving songs like ʽStreet Jesusʼ and ʽLover A Lotʼ,
there is really no feel that these were recorded with any other purpose than «hey, we still have to prove that we can do
another ʽToys In The Atticʼ». Forget it. They can no longer do even another
ʽFeverʼ.
Then there are the genuinely dorky bits. The
album's equivalent of ʽBack In The Saddleʼ, for instance, is ʽOut Go The
Lightsʼ, with the sexual bravado culminating in a chorus that will just have to go down the annals — or the
drain, one of the two: "If you wanna take a lookie cookie / Tonight might
be your lucky". And ʽCan't Stop Loving Youʼ is a duet with American Idol
winner Carrie Underwood — and the song sounds like it belongs on American Idol, one of those «neo-country» pieces of
garbage that even a post-Permanent
Vacation Aerosmith should be ashamed of being associated with.
And it's loooooong. Sixty seven minutes of one non-descript
piece of muzak after another (occasionally my brain even fails to register the
pauses between the tracks). In this totally draggy atmosphere, there are almost
no high- or lowlights: even the Diane Warren ballad is no better or worse than
everything else. Perry gets two lead vocals, including the one on ʽFreedom Fighterʼ, a perfunctory anti-war rant that sounds
as if made on order; it ain't even no ʽWalk On Downʼ — back in the days of Get A Grip, you could at least count on
old man Perry to strike out some old-timey rock'n'roll excitement as an
antithesis to the band's generally glossy sound, but here there is no
difference: the glossy sound has worn off some of the gloss, and the exciting
bits have lost some of the excitement. It's all just one big gray blob of sonic
murk.
Music
From Another Dimension! is not
a general offense to good taste (at least, not until the American Idol woman enters the studio): even if they still wanted
to, Aerosmith simply no longer have it in them to spearhead the «MTV taking
over the world» movement. But, much like every bit of original material that
their forefathers, The Rolling Stones, recorded in the 21st century, this is
first and foremost merely a reminder — that this here band, Aerosmith, is
still with us, whether we like it or not. Naturally, they have every right to
issue a reminder like that — and we have every right to remind them that this
is nothing more than just a reminder. By giving it a certified thumbs down,
for instance.
Check "Music From Another Dimension!" (MP3) on Amazon
"an outrageous offense to good taste"
ReplyDeleteMaybe that's why I like classic late period Aerosmith better than you do. I refer to Uriah Heep once again, those absolute masters of bad taste.
"No one has bothered writing a single new interesting riff."
Looks like that other old dumb band, Deep Purple, understood the importance of this point much better - and I'm not a fan of Steve Morse.
"Take my advice"
Done. Plus the first few bars of the second song. Well, it is not as bad as you suggested, but I don't see any reason to spend money or even time on this either. Wall of sound masking lack of creativity - something rockbands all too often use. The result can be nothing more than pleasant muzak.
For verification I just listend to "Kiss tomorrow goodbuy" once again (live Montreux 2006).
Yup.
Comparing Aerosmith to Deep Purple - or, Heaven save us, the Rolling Stones! - is just...well, please just don't do it! I can't understand why anyone laments over Aerosmith "selling out" to MTV, Hollywood, and American Idol when it was always clear that they were "rock stars" first and musicians second. Let's face it, they're the kind of guys who spent a considerable portion of the 70's kicking themselves over not coming up with Kiss's makeup gimmick first.
DeleteMaybe that's true, but that doesn't diminish the awesomeness that is the crazy riff to "Draw the Line".
DeleteMaybe Aerosmith never really sold out, maybe they were always just a bunch of corporate suckers ever since they got their first recording contract, but no matter what the reason is, I believe (and obviously George does as well) that Aerosmith used to rcok, and now they no longer do. Surely that is cause for lamentation.
Well, Anton, it's no sin to grow old. We'll all suffer a diminishing of our basic potency and motor skills as we reach senior age. But if Aerosmith go down in history as the "prototypical kick ass American rock band" as they threaten to do, it'll be a goddamned shame. As little as they move me, I'd rather see the Ramones walk away with that title - or even the Stooges. Or, screw it, even Boston! As cheesy as they were (and they were extremely cheesy), Boston were definitely about the music and nothing else. It was calculated down to the last second, but they were honest about it, and at least never pretended to be anything but big, dumb, ultimately insignificant radio fodder. At the end of the day, I'd rather have a bit of that than the faux-heroic ersatz Mick 'n Keef routine of TMZ's favorite feuding couple, Tyler and Perry.
DeleteThe prototypical kickass American rock bands are Cheap Trick and Van Halen.
DeleteYou might be right, Malx, but I have a soft spot for Aerosmith - can't help it. For a bunch of corporate suckers or "rock stars" they have delivered quite some good songs. Dream On is even excellent. But be comforted, never in my textbook will Aerosmith be the "prototypical kick ass American rock band". That title would rather go to Metallica or even Nirvana. Or Jefferson Airplane if you want some old geezers.
ReplyDeleteStill I like Tyler and Perry. Now and then.
As the subject of "rock star" and "sell out" is concerned - the biggest sell out in the history of music is a certain WA Mozart. He never put a single note on paper without getting paid and knew a few things about stardom as well.
ReplyDeleteAt the other side of this spectrum we have Gentle Giant. Derek Shulman explicitly stated in an interview that the main goal of the band was to make it big.
So why blame Aerosmith for it? All I care for is the notes.
I think half this album is outtakes -at least the leadoff single, "legendary child" is an outtake from get a grip, which means they didn't actually team up with vallance to write a new song-. Haven't listened to the whole album, only that song and the second single "What love could have been". I found both of them rather bland. But then a decade ago I found "jaded" bland upon release and now I kinda like it, mostly cause of the drumming. Who knows how will i find these songs ten years from now?
ReplyDeleteI'm from Boston. Never could stand these guys. Joe Perry's an okay player but a conceited asshole as well. The rest are mediocre, 'Nuff said.
ReplyDelete